Stephen Putbrese


Stephen is the lead pastor of Isaiah. In addition to preaching and teaching, he is also responsible for long-term vision, oversight of operations, and development of leaders. Stephen’s background is in finance, and he worked briefly at an investment firm before becoming a pastor. In 2016, he married Betsy, a physical therapist with UW Health. They have an infant daughter named Anna.

Jackson Scalero

Worship Leader

Jackson is the worship leader at Isaiah. He is responsible for leading our worship team and developing new musicians. He graduated from Southern Illinois University in 2020 with a degree in Industrial Management and Applied Engineering and works in management at Chick-fil-A. He and his wife, Rachel, married in May 2020.

Anna Sunderlage

Kids Director

Anna leads the Kids Program at Isaiah. She develops the kids curriculum we use on Sunday mornings and ensures that our children have a safe and secure environment. Anna has a degree in Education and taught high school science for two years before moving to Madison. She recently started her own home organization business. She and her husband, Brent, have been married since 2016.

Connie Gregory


Connie organizes the church's finances, budgets, and bank accounts. Before moving to Madison to help start Isaiah, she was the bookkeeper at Vine Church in Carbondale for 13 years. She and her husband, Michael, have been married since 2002 and have three children.